Should I Learn To Drive Manual Or Automatic

Deciding whether to learn to drive a manual or an automatic car is a common dilemma for new drivers in the UK, and there are strong arguments for both. Here's a breakdown to help you make your choice:

​

The UK Driving Licence Implication is Key

​

This is the most crucial point:

​

• Pass in a Manual: Your driving licence will allow you to drive both manual and automatic cars. This gives you maximum flexibility for future car ownership, rentals, and borrowing vehicles.

• Pass in an Automatic: Your driving licence will have an endorsement (code 78) restricting you to driving only automatic vehicles. If you later decide you want to drive a manual, you'd need to take additional lessons in a manual car and pass another driving test.

 

Learning to Drive an Automatic Car

 

Pros:

 

• Easier to Learn: Without the clutch pedal and manual gear stick, there's less coordination required. This often leads to quicker progress, fewer lessons, and potentially a faster test pass. You can focus more on road awareness, steering, and hazard perception.

• Less Stressful in Traffic: Stop-and-go traffic (common in places like Ryde town centre or ferry queues) is far less taxing in an automatic, as you don't need to constantly shift gears or worry about stalling.

• Smoother Ride: Automatic transmissions typically provide a smoother, more seamless acceleration without the jerks that can occur during manual gear changes.

• Increasing Popularity: Automatic cars are becoming more common, especially with the rise of electric vehicles (which are almost universally automatic). If you envision driving newer cars or EVs in the future, an automatic licence aligns well.

• Easier Hill Starts: Automatic cars won't roll back on hills, simplifying a common challenge for new drivers.

 

Cons:

​

• License Restriction: As mentioned, you'll be limited to driving automatics unless you take another test. This can be a significant limitation if you need to drive a manual for work, rent one abroad, or borrow a friend's car.

• Limited Car Choices: While automatics are gaining ground, manual cars still offer a wider variety of models, particularly in the used car market, and often at lower prices.

• Potentially Higher Costs: Automatic cars can sometimes be more expensive to buy, insure, and repair due to their more complex technology.

• Less Engaging for Some: For those who enjoy a more "involved" driving experience and feeling completely in control of the vehicle's mechanics, an automatic can feel less engaging.

 

Learning to Drive a Manual Car

​

Pros:

​

• Full Licence Flexibility: This is the biggest advantage. A manual licence means you can drive any car, manual or automatic. This is incredibly practical for buying used cars, renting vehicles when travelling, or borrowing from friends and family.

• Wider Car Availability: Manual cars are still very common, especially in the UK and Europe, giving you more options when it comes to purchasing or hiring vehicles.

• Often Cheaper to Buy: Manual versions of cars are typically less expensive than their automatic counterparts.

• More Control: Many drivers feel they have a greater sense of control over the car's power delivery and engine braking in a manual, which can be beneficial in certain conditions (e.g., on steep hills or icy roads).

• More Engaging Driving Experience: For some, the active process of shifting gears makes driving more enjoyable and gives a feeling of truly "driving" the car.

• Potentially Better Fuel Economy (Historically): While modern automatics are very efficient, historically, manuals could offer slightly better fuel economy. This gap is closing, but a well-driven manual can still be efficient.

 

Cons:

​

• Steeper Learning Curve: Mastering clutch control and smooth gear changes takes time, practice, and coordination. This often means more lessons and a longer period before you're ready for your test.

• More Challenging in Traffic: Constantly engaging the clutch and shifting gears in heavy traffic can be tiring and frustrating. Hill starts in traffic can also be daunting for beginners.

• Risk of Stalling: New manual drivers frequently stall the car, which can be embarrassing and disruptive, especially at busy junctions.

• More Complex Driving: It requires more multi-tasking and coordination of hands and feet.

• Potential for Wear and Tear: Improper use of the clutch can lead to premature wear, which can be an expensive repair.

 

So, Which Should You Choose?

​

• Choose Automatic if:

  • You want the quickest and easiest path to getting your licence.

  • You feel anxious about learning to drive or struggle with coordination.

  • You anticipate driving primarily in urban areas with heavy traffic.

  • You only plan to drive newer cars or electric vehicles in the future.

  • You have a physical disability that makes operating a clutch difficult.

• Choose Manual if:

  • You want the most flexibility and freedom in the types of cars you can drive.

  • You're on a tighter budget for buying a car after passing your test.

  • You enjoy a more hands-on and engaging driving experience.

  • You're prepared for a slightly longer and potentially more challenging learning process.

  • You might need to drive a wider variety of cars (e.g., for work, rentals, or borrowing).

 

Recommendation:

If you are unsure, it's generally recommended to learn manual if you can. The flexibility of being able to drive both types of cars is a significant advantage in the long run. Even if you end up buying an automatic, having the manual licence gives you options.

However, if the thought of learning a manual causes significant anxiety or you need to get on the road as quickly as possible for practical reasons (like a job), then learning automatic is a perfectly valid and increasingly popular choice. There's no shame in it – the most important thing is to become a safe and confident driver.

Consider speaking with local driving instructors in Ryde. They can often offer an introductory lesson in both types of cars to help you get a feel for which suits you best.